Date: November 9, 2026
Author: Dr. Cohen
Medical Director, Specialty Experts
Two numbers describe today’s malpractice environment, and they point in opposite directions.
According to Robert White, president of The Doctors Company, speaking on a Medical Economics podcast, about one in 21 physicians was sued in 2025, the lowest rate since 1973. In the same year, the average payment reported to the National Practitioner Data Bank reached $514,000, the highest on record.
Fewer cases. Much bigger stakes. For attorneys on either side, that changes how much rides on every expert decision.
What Is a Nuclear Verdict?
A nuclear verdict is an award over $10 million. White says one now lands somewhere in the country roughly once a week. Awards over $100 million, sometimes called thermonuclear, are no longer unheard of. The AMA reports that the average of the top 50 malpractice verdicts climbed from $32 million in 2022 to $56 million in 2024.
Why Does One Verdict Matter So Much?
Very few malpractice cases reach trial; White puts it at about 7%. When they do, the defense wins roughly six of every seven. But the seventh becomes the benchmark. A single large plaintiff’s verdict resets the settlement value of comparable cases that never see a courtroom.
That makes every trial-bound case a potential reference point for dozens of others. The quality of the medical testimony in that one case has consequences well beyond it.
Where Do Experts Fit In?
In a high-severity environment, the expert isn’t a box to check before a disclosure deadline. The expert often shapes how the jury understands what happened in the first place. A clear, credible physician can be the difference between a defense verdict and a number that follows similar cases for years. An expert who loses the jury, however qualified, can do the opposite.
This is why the timing problem matters more than it used to. When the best-suited physician is already committed elsewhere, the cost of settling for a second choice is higher than ever.
What Should Attorneys Do Differently?
• Identify the specialty early. Know which experts the case needs before discovery pressure builds.
• Vet for communication, not just credentials. A ten-minute call tells you whether an expert educates or lectures.
• Prepare for trial from the start. Treat every case as one that might be tried, because its value depends on whether the other side believes it will be.
• Watch your venue. White names Georgia among the states with the most nuclear verdicts, with 33 in the past four years.
The verdicts are larger, and the margin for a weak expert is smaller. The attorneys who plan for that early are the ones best positioned when a case doesn’t settle.
Do the medicine. Let Specialty Experts do the logistics.
Preparing for an upcoming case? Let's start the conversation.
specialtyexperts.com | contact@specialtyexperts.com